With makeup you can do either, but now I am leaning toward the apple green. I had both the red and green in my cart last night, but didn't purchase either. The apple green looked so good on Amy and now you I might have to go for it.

Tough call - but I LOVED the first picture when it first loaded - that color mixes so nice with denim. The apple green is a bit bright for me but you know what you really like.

Ok, you already have a LOT of feedback, but I'll chime in.

I clicked on the first pic and said, "nice." I clicked on the second picture and said, "Ooh nice!"

They're both great jackets on you. Either one fits your style and suits your coloring. I give an edge to the apple green because the color is a bit more unusual and refreshing at the moment, but it depends on which one makes your heart sing.

I love the first jacket best on you, the color is gorgeous and the fit, perfection. I can see the apple green jacket as being a little more hip or fun, but I still like the first one best, can you go wrong with a classic jacket in a great flattering color? Whats the goal for the jacket, adding a workhorse or adding a trend or statement piece to your wardrobe?

I like both on you - you look great in them! - but my eye prefers the first one.