Ag, maybe you had a faulty pair? They feel fine.

I am in the might group, if you arn't sure about it send them back. You don't need them cluttering up your closet and life as a reminder.
I am really trying to be definite and 100% about whether to keep things that I buy. Any amount of doubt = return.
In the case of shoes if they aren't immediately comfortable they never will be. I remember when I was younger buying a pair of Ralph Lauren shoes ( way before he was as big a designer as he is now) and thinking they would stretch out...they never did. Lesson learned.

I have sent a couple of things to consignment rather than return with the cost of shipping. Since I send stuff on a seasonal basis it's easier. I've only ordered shoes once for this reason since I have hard to fit feet.

Keep! They are so fun. You can have a simple outfit like skinny jeans and white tee, and the outfit will look put together with these boots.

If you change your mind there are already several takers on YLF - yay for that.

It is late to be selling boots so I would keep them until next fall/winter and if you don't wear them offer them for sale here or consignment. Sending them back costs to much and for me would be too much hassle for no satisfaction.

I think they are definitely keepers. Even if they end up being "special occasion" wear (meaning that I simply have to be in the mood to wear) I think for the price and the fun factor (they are silver and awesome) I would hang on to them. You might find that you will wear them more than you think. If not, there is always the style exchange. Mostly win-win n my book.

If they are comfortable, keep them. They are seriously awesome and look great on you.

I bought a pair of heels from 6pm and with the price it just wasn't worth it to me to return them. So they are sitting in my closet waiting for an opportunity to wear them...Next time I will be really really careful. I hate having things I don't use regularly. (But the shoes are really cute, but a little on the high side.)

What size are they? (just in case)