Carla, nice suggestion!

Pink is in the lead.....by a long shot....

Fighting the lead...I like the Navy!

Queen Duplication reporting in here to say BOTH. It just seems so practical and easy to wear! And in our climate it's a three-season dress.

(Full disclosure, I was leaning towards pink but your response to Runcarla solidified my Both vote.)

Oh pink by a mile .

Beautiful dresses. With your colouring, I think navy looks better than bright pink. And colours like green, teal, turquoise, peach or orange would have been even better.

Pink Rules

I like the navy more with your darker hair!

Well, you know I am going to say BOTH!

But if it has to be one, I vote PINK!

And send the navy to me.

The pink is THRILLING.

Oh, the PINK.

Pink, for sure! It’s a show-stopper.

To my eye, the navy looks Serious. But wouldn’t you get more work done wearing the pink? On the other hand, it seems like the navy would go better with the green you want to add this year. But my bottom line vote is for the pink because it seems to be a wardrobe hole.

Pink!! I think pink would contrast VERY nicely with any sour green items you add this year.

Um, both?! They both look so good, Angie. I love the pink, but the navy is all kinds of wonderful, too.

Plus your hair looks UH-MAzing!! So good.

You need a navy dress for every occasion, really? You clearly have a strong inclination, so just go with that. Either one would be great with sour green, and with your hair, just in different ways.

Ahem, cough, cough -- Stag Fash, in this unbiased Queen Blue's opinion, everyone needs a navy dress for every occasion! (Joke, but only barely, because I really do believe that I, at least, need multiple navy dresses! And I have the dresses to prove it! Or at least I had them -- I've recently retired 3.)

Suz, Queen Navy Dress, i salute you from my tower of Skirts and Dresses of All Hues of Blue!

NAVY. And your hair is stunning! I get it now!

Hmmm, this fuchsia pink is different from some of the warmer hot pinks you have worn, I think. Are you moving toward cooler pinks? I can’t assess it that well on my monitor , except that you can wear so many color tones quite well.
I do agree that in terms of what turns up, a more sophisticated navy dress may surface, while it’s less likely to find the bright color in a dress with the length & drape of this one. So if you’re being conserving of closet space, the pink has more “ impact” value while still being ladylike.
I’d consider the seasons a bit and toppers. The pink wants nude legs ( including nude hose though) while the navy might be easier to winterize.

Thanks, everyone! For the giggles, justifications, reasoning, and cheerleading

CarolS and Column, thanks for the hair compliments!

unfrumped, not moving towards cooler pinks! Warm and acidic looks best, although I wear a cold white and navy well too. Won't Winterize this dress so nude hosiery and bare legs it is. Good versatility thoughts though, so thanks!

If I keep ONE - I'm undecided.

Really like what Tanya, Suz and SarahD8 mentioned about possibly keeping both. I got the one for a song with Nordies notes which helps.

Full disclosure for JenniNZ. Greg loves both, but has a slight preference for the navy. If I keep both, Greg will be extra happy!

Sleeping on it...

Very nice. In pic 1 I feel the glasses frames especially pop in the navy.
I still can’t believe I might be suggesting navy over the fuchsia since I am obsessed with fuchsia lately…

I vote navy! It looks *amazing* with the blue glasses, and I think it highlights the new caramel notes in your hair so beautifully.

PINK! But why not both!

I think you've said that bright colors make you happy, so pink fills the bill!

Oh man. Hard. I’d personally go navy for me… lol, so that says you should go pink

I like both, but if it could be only one, I’d go navy!!

Pink! The perfect dress to wear on Valentines Day.

my vote even though i am late to the party is both. if you decide to keep just one the navy. i love both on you but the navy is elegant! I have had that dress in my finds for a bit.
I am loving it the navy.

That is a nice problem to have. Like Sharan and Debbie, I like both dresses. Although they have the same cut, they look very different, so I would suggest keeping both. Navy is more elegant, pink is more fun, both are great finds.