I love the green silky coat you already own. It is similar to the blue one, but just different enough that it could serve a different purpose like Janet says. I'm another vote for an outfit lab with the old one and new one to compare before you decide.

I like the green coat better than the blue coat, but that’s just me and green. I do think the blue one has a different vibe because it is oversized and has bracelet sleeves. It’s a bit retro. Maybe you prefer that style?

Nemosmom, thank you, it is a good idea to try on both properly with different outfits.

Brooklyn, thank you. You are right, the blue one is more retro. I like retro. On the other hand, I like the green colour better on me... hm, not easy

Am I in the minority? I prefer the blue to the green because it's more retro with the wider shorter sleeve. Prettier silhouette to my eye. Both are different enough to keep.

Oh, they’re totally different to my eye and I, personally, cannot have too many coats (!)

Thank you, Angie, for popping by! Now I am really tempted to keep the blue coat. Thankfully, I have a few days more to contemplate and try on with other outfits as well to see if it would work with the cream trousers I have, dark blue ones and maybe jeans.

Rachy, thanks! Totally different.... hm
My problem is that I cannot have too many of anything, lol
And here, I tried to show some restraint in my “needs”

Going against the tide, I feel like the blue coat’s color lacks the drama for your high contrast coloring. Your green coat is much more flattering color wise. In terms of everything else, I love both coats. I will also allow that my screens may not be accurate and the blue coat may look quite different up close and in person.

Thank you very much DonnaF for chiming in. I prefer the green colour on me too. The blue is a little soft, muted, for what I would think would be perfect.

Hi Katerina I have been a bit busy to chime in but here is a little time before bed I like the cream jacket in the first pics best, the pics with the ape. And I am with Donna F on liking the green out of sight more than the blue. It seems much more dramatic which seems more you somehow x

I love the blue coat the best probably because it is retro. Both coats are lovely, you look gorgeous in the green coat too.

Jenni NZ, thank you for taking your time, much appreciated advice!

Bijou, thank you for coming back giving more feedback!