I think this looks great as an outfit, although I would probably add shear black hose. I vote keep both with the only caveat that it is a bold look, so you have to feel good being bold. I bet the burgundy bootie will be more versatile than you expect.

OK, you've totally sold me on those burgundy booties. Those are stunning.

I really like the sweater, too! Looks great on you and fits perfectly with your style.