I like #1 - I don't like the extra colour in #2; seems distracting to the general integrity of the outfit.

I think #2 is more you because of the playful tails and the hand-knit vest, great colors. The straight across lines of the vest are not working to my eye though, I think I would prefer a vest with a scoop neck and the bottom hem a little longer and curved to play better with the shirt tails and jacket.

Angie, no fair! I want a samosa!

To all of you who chose #2 because it's more original and unique - I think this is the main reason why I prefer this version as well. I really like Celeste's term "unexpected but perfect." I think this is what I should strive for in all my outfits!

Vildy, I admit I do worry about emphasizing my middle sometimes, even though objectively I know it's ridiculous. And I do have days where I'd probably change to a darker shirt because the white is too glaring in the middle. So I totally get where you are coming from. And I hadn't noticed about the neckline of the top echoing the notches on the blazer! That's really cool!

Interesting also that there are votes for the proportions of 1 as well as those of 2… personally (like Sveta I think) I find the proportions of #1 to be a little too much pants and not enough top. It may just be that I rarely tuck tops into skinnies though. I think it only works here because I have a big, heavy belt. (Truth is that I did it because the length of the top untucked seemed awkward.)

Diana, don't you find that an interesting phenomenon -- that exactly the qualities some like in an outfit, others say are absent -- and vice versa!? Even when we're considering two outfits that are remarkably similar, with similar components. And in your case, even the same jacket! And colours!

I do think some it comes down to personal figure flattery priorities and style preferences that people -- try as they may-- can't get past.

Suz, I think it's a good thing that people are responding based on their personal priorities/tastes, because it means that there isn't one of them that is objectively and clearly worse than the other. In other words, we're getting pretty good at putting together decent outfits on a regular basis!

Ok, this is a tough one. But I think I am going with #2. Maybe because there is a repeat of the yellow color (more or less). I like the vest a lot. I do like #1 too though and the blue jeans and boots look great. Just wondering if another sour color (scarf, necklace) would change my vote.

That's what I told myself, too, Diana! I think there is truth in it, too.

And I love that opinions in both cases have been varied. I really like to hear people's actual reactions. Of course who knows if they would feel the same if they saw the outfits IRL -- I suspect IRL I would be so taken by your face that I'd barely notice the difference between the two outfits -- it would register that you looked great and were wearing a fun jacket and a cool hand knit and that would be that.

Hmm, now I am wondering whether chopping my head off in the photos would change anything... I know usually Angie says that you can't assess outfits without the head, because your face/hair/specs are part of the equation.

Shevia, that's an interesting idea. I may have to try adding my orange lace handknit scarf, as I haven't worn it for ages. (That would also add a "unique" element to #1!)

#1. In #2, I think the 3 hemlines compete and the vest takes away from the pop of the trim color in the jacket. Now going back to read the responses to see if I got it right!

I prefer #1 because I like how the belt defines your waist. I had a hard time deciding why, though. Also, your smile is brighter in #1. (I know, that is not supposed to count.)

#2! Did you make the sweater? That outfit looks more like "you."

Ooh, I'm glad someone is continuing the game. I think this should be a regular feature on the forum, like WIW.

I like #1 mainly for the reason that there is less going on. In #2, all I really see is the green sweater as opposed to you. Also, it seems like the hem at the bottom of the sweater is not sitting quite straight, which distracts me. I also like the clearer waistline definition in outfit #1.

I like 1, it's simple and clean.

I'm voting 1. I loved seeing you in it. I've read your both threads and while I both appreciate your affection for the originality, which is a lot more showcased in 2, I also think both of these look like you so I'm going with what may inspire you to experiment more.

Initially I loved the sleek, clean lines of #1. But more and more I am appreciating the way you have modified #2 to suit you by elongating the shirt tails and adding the funky, cropped, detailed top.

I am not on the fence. Both outfits make you look amazing and I vote for both!!! Awesome work!

I wanted to say that when I mentioned visual weight, I didn't intend anything connected with actual weight or appearance of it. I meant that, to me, all the attention getting lines and contrasts and pattern were happening in that area. I was talking about the design elements all competing for my attention within a small area, as though they were in a small pan of a balance scale and weighing it down with focus demands.

in the thumbnail photos, i prefer #1, in the full photo's i prefer #2. i like the both, but i think i would prefer #1 with a bootie or shoe (maybe in a lighter color).

Both are awesome. Being a fellow owner of this blazer, I like it every outfit but if I really have to choose, I will go with #2. It is a little unexpected so looks more interesting. #1 is something I would totally wear. I think I need to sit with Angie on the bench with this one.

Voting nr 1. Cleaner, simplier lines, still interesting with the piping and contrast boots. Most fllatering, younger and curent to my eyes. No fuss, no cry:-).

#2, because of how I perhaps reductively read your personality, taste and interests! The fresh green vest, a little old-fashioned element that is contemporanised by the jeans and blazer, the organic and almost botanical quality of the pattern... very very Diana to me.

I like #2 for the individuality but both outfits are really great. I think I might like #2 with jeans as well.

Team #2 was well in the lead last night, but Team #1 is catching up!

So I think there are a few different ways people are approaching this choice:

--which one they think looks more "me".
--which one appeals to their personal tastes.
--which one is objectively more flattering (but I'm not sure this can be divorced from the first two).

I think they are all valid points. I also now have even more admiration for Angie and other stylists who have to dress other people. I'm not sure I'd be able to do it without injecting my own personal tastes and biases.

I hope I'm not too late, I'm another #2 vote. I associate a artsy element to your style and #2 has that for me with the top untucked and the interesting details and colors with the lime top. #1 is nice too, but is a bit classic which I don't associate with your style. This is a very interesting exercise!

Late here but I prefer 2 both objectively and on you. The color and layering add interest, and knowing that the hand knit is your signature makes me choose it for you.

This one was tough for me. I prefer 1, but throw in a plus or minus 5 for a margin of error and it becomes a crap shoot for me. : )

I know, lots of help ! I can't explain why I prefer 1 slightly, I just do.

I like both and would wear both. For some reason I prefer 1 because of the balance