Joy, I think Angie might be onto something. A wider skirt would look brilliant on you at a longer length.
I think you and I discussed the A-line and fit and flare issue some time ago and agreed that for some reason we had trouble with them. In my case, it's not my leg shape. (My legs are, ahem, far from skinny!)
Instead, something about being rather straight-shaped makes some A-lines and fit and flares look ... sad? on me. And then, at my age, especially with grey hair, some fit and flares look and feel too youthful, even silly.
But I've made a happy rediscovery this year. First, A-lines will work if they are a stiffer, crisper fabric. A knit (and even a light woven) sort of hangs pitifully. Whereas a crisper fabric lends structure and definition and works with my own angles.
Meanwhile, a fit and flare with a wide skirt will look great if the length is sufficient. Too short = too youthful/ off-balanced/ ill-proportioned on me. Midi length = elegant. For me, it has to be below the knee and longer.
Angie, that striped dress is just as great as the navy on you! Wow! (Plus is that the loft I spy? And, can I just say how jealous I am of your cute mules and flats! I wish I could find the versions that would work for me.)