Brie, I did not know until I used it. It comes off just with warm water in big long pieces.

Scarlet: I read your descriptions of lashes and mascara with wonder. Honestly, I just started wearing mascara a few months ago. Before that, I had the odd mascara I'd dig out every 4-5 months. I've never given my eyelashes much thought and even less thought about what type of look I'm after. The best I can say is that I like it when I curl my eyelashes with an eyelash curler and I like black mascara especially because the ends of my lashes are light. Now that I think about it though, I would guess that my lashes are at least regular length but maybe sparse compared to others. So that would mean a mascara that "fills in" my lashes somehow?

Thank you, Anna, for the recommendation. It sounds like the Loreal is up to the task!

rabbit: I wish I could understand your eye makeup a little better, with the white and brown. I would try that for sure.

Thanks for starting this thread, BrieN. I had to stop wearing mascara due to an eye problem, but now want to have a go again. Most mascaras smudge on me as well, and after reading all the good things about the tube variation, I just ordered one from Blinc. Very curious to try it out.

I often have these same issues. I find Lancome's Definicil's works best for me.