Two boot posts in one day! Exciting.
I live in Vancouver, so basically the same climate as Seattle, and this is my boot list (which I feel is complete, but I never say no to adding to it if I fall in love with a new pair), in order of how often I wear them:
navy blue Hunter wellies (not the height of style, but it rains all the damn time here)
brown Fluevog Radio BBC (flat lace-up ankle boots)
black Fluevog Babycakes (mid-calf, sturdy 3" heel; have buttons and look Victorian)
gray Fluevog Operetta Giulias (ankle booties with 2.5" stacked heel)
wine red Operetta Giulias (same as gray ones)
white Tsubo knee-high flats with rubber sole
green and navy houndstooth/suede Converse (mid-calf, lace-up with inside zip)
dark brown suede Rocket dog boots (like Uggs but cuter, with one-inch platform)
black Fluevog Libby Smiths (mid-calf; narrow 2.75" heel; have red buttons -- love these and save them for evenings out)
tan Fluevog Bethsaidas (peep-toe ankle boots; very cute but limited wearing opportunities where I live!)
sand-coloured Ugg boots (mostly worn as slippers)
white Ilse Jacobssen lace-up wellies (not sure why I rarely wear these)
So, as you can probably guess, my vote is yay for the lace-up boots. You don't really have very many boots, and if you really want some lace-ups, then go for it!