Shevia, you make an excellent point. All clothing should be cleaned whether bought new or used. The used stuff can hold up very well. It has already found it's true size and probably will not shrink.
My DSIL wears large sizes (16-18 and higher now) and has bought nearly her whole wardrobe thrifting for years, including loungewear and pj's and robes. She also has found beautiful expensive yarns to knit and much more. Her whole Christmas tree is stunning and thrifted, including the tree itself.

I'm coming back to this to start taking notes. There is so much helpful information here. I admit being limited to the Good Will and there have been compromises. Those compromises usually occur when I find something of such good quality that I have to own it .... even it if a little off. I am resolving to stop that this minute.

I have had limited success in consignment stores. I have noticed that consignment stores in larger urban centers have a better selection and I am more likely to find something that works for me.
My biggest successes have been handbags and other accessories. I have bought designer handbags, jewellery and scarves in consignment stores. I found a store that "specializes in designer bags" near me in Florida. I check that one out a few times during my stay in Florida.

For me, I'm also finding that I'd rather pay a little more for an item with a generous return policy than a little less for a final-sale item. I can't say that I come out ahead money-wise with this strategy, but I do end up with a lot less chaff in my closet. I have to be especially careful with eBay and other online venues. When you're only paying ~$10 for something, you'll be loathe to spend $10 to ship it back if it doesn't meet your expectations. I have had some luck getting price adjustments and partial/whole refunds from eBay and Etsy sellers when the item doesn't match the description in terms of colour, size, quality, whatever.

Sarah, regarding when I've "checked" or exhausted my secondhand options: I keep a brainstorm list of things I would like to find, as well as a list of things I'm not allowed to buy. I put an asterisk next to anything that would be useful immediately, to remind myself I should try to find before the season is over. For me, at the moment, it's solid-colour knit layering tops -- lighter than a sweater, more substantial than a tee. I have dismal luck with knits when shopping secondhand, so most likely I'll end up purchasing these new. Also, I have very specific colours in mind, as these would be outfit-completers, so retail may be my most efficient option.

I also need to replace my favourite black jeans and hope to find one pair of light wash jeans for spring. I have plenty of pants, and I often have success with thrifted jeans, so these I'm willing to wait for. I'll continue to check Etsy and Ebay, and I will have one cruise through the stores where I have consignment accounts (one has a great vintage denim section). Living far away from everything, I've really had to tamp down my FOMO, but I tell myself that thrifting is all karma anyway. I *should* be able to find something over the next 2-3 months. If I don't find anything by April, I will probably start looking at Madewell, etc, but there is little guarantee, with jeans, that I'll have better luck buying new anyway.

Shevia

Great website! Bookmarked.

I have always liked secondhand shopping. When I was young I was drawn in by the chance to find quirky things, in my 20s I liked the quantity I could buy. Now in my mid 30s I’m more aware of the ethical issues (both human and animal) and also appreciate the ability to buy better quality at a lower price. I still enjoy the thrill of the hunt, but I don’t always have time for it, especially in-person. Almost all of my secondhand shopping is online these days. I’m also mindful that I do not want all of my clothes to me used. I don’t have an ideal ratio, though.

Practical strategies:

Look for something fairly specific. Brands, colors, styles (narrows down search terms, helps minimize random purchases).

New, like new, or excellent condition

Seller accepts returns

Honestly assess if the item deserves to be in my closet and return or donate immediately if it does not.

Very occasionally I will see one of Angie’s ensables and buy a thrifted piece to try out the look.

Fun thread

I had to come back to this thread and read more carefully! A few thoughts:
Regarding the ick factor, and I certainly don't mean to contradict what I said before, but I suggest you clean or disinfect everything you buy second hand, even NWT or with dry cleaning labels. At least in the store where I worked, all the clothes were piled together before they got to the racks.
Regarding churn, I took in tons of stuff that was all wrong for me when I started. That is why YLF has been invaluable to help me understand what works and does not, which applies to all fashion old and new. And of course, I still do make mistakes, which I sell or give away.
Regarding Angie's post today about buying for summer, even at retail we often need to buy out of season.
Regarding knits, it does depend on how good your stores are, but some of my hardiest and best knits are second hand vintage cashmere.
I have learned tons from this thread, thanks for starting it Sarah!

I need to amend my knit comment. Shevia is right. Do look/feel the sweaters. I ignored them at thrift stores until I started looking for 100% wool for my aunt to felt for her projects. I found some great sweaters for myself but really needed to ignore size tags.

I enjoy thrifting if I'm not looking for something specific. I try to keep my needs really general - such as looking for dresses. The thrift store I go to most often is organized by color and type, not size. I don't have a problem with the ick factor for clothes because I wash them as soon as I get home, but I can't get past the ick factor when it comes to shoes. I only go every few months when my sister is in town so I don't have quite the same FOMO problem. Now I go even less often because a bunch of ladies in my neighborhood host a clothing exchange twice a year and I always end up with a pile of new clothes that reduces my need to shop for something new (to me). I also enjoy thrifting because I can try out new trends or colors for a low cost. If the item doesn't work out for me, I don't feel bad that I spent a bunch of money.

Almost all my clothing is thrifted. I do it because I can engineer my shopping experience. The more I see of something, the more sated I become so I shun mall stores. Quality in fabric and construction appeals to me, though there are a surprising number of brands known for this whose garments are sorely deficient. I can do my own alterations or refashions so I see the insides of garments underneath the lining. Plenty of brands that are very costly do not bother to finish their seams and leave them to fray. Also, for preference, I would rather have interfacing that is not fused to the garment because that relates to how a garment molds to you and how it moves.

I might be happiest with unlimited funds where I could instruct my stylist to provide what I wanted but that isn't the case. I don't really like shopping - not for any body issues - I just like clothing.

I am also time poor. Plus, even with limiting my exposure to all the stimuli of the store experience, about an hour is plenty for me. And that includes try on time.

I've chosen 3 main stores to shop at. All are church thrifts. I like knowing that my money is going to the church for its needed upkeep or to its missions, even though I don't belong to any of those churches and am not Christian. The prices are pretty much rock bottom. Returns would be possible in the form of donating it back - which people who don't try on often do. I don't do that because the stores I've chosen are small and that affords me less distraction. One, I go to weekly and I've been going for well over a decade and a half and there are many regulars and it's also a social experience as you get to know about people's lives.

One practical drawback is the try on. You have to use the ladies room, though depending on the garment, some stores do have a wall mirror or a place where you can see yourself reflected. It can be almost impossible to find places to hang what you are about to try on or your own clothing. I end up placing my clothing right on the floor in one place. In another, I use the baby changing table. What doesn't kill you makes you stronger, eh. Sometimes the mirrors are like in a funhouse and the lighting is the worst possible. That also goes for the lighting in the store portion itself. Often, they are using the spaghetti bulbs with their yellowed lighting that is bad that you have to take what you think is a brown garment into the next room that does have some sunlight and where you are surprised to see that it's purple. The lighting can be so dim that I take reading glasses to try to be able to discover what the fabric content is or the size. I need a miner's headlamp.

One odd thing I've found in thrifting is that I follow the trends to decide what I might want to experiment with and I believe that runway is about 3 years ahead of what most folks are finding and buying retail. For some reason, people tend to donate items that have strong similarities to what is "new". They give up on them exactly at the moment they have begun to have some fashion currency.

I do have a lot of clothing and a significant rate of "churn". I guess I'm very fickle. I've been successful at ebay shopping but I keep vowing to stop. It's much more expensive than the church thrifts plus even if I think I've found the most comfortable shirt in the world, as I did recently, and then buy up some multiples in a few other colors, pretty soon I see that, yes, but it's only that comfortable worn outside but tucked in it actually even looks uncomfortable because it doesn't blouse at all, not a millimeter. So it's not The One Shirt To Rule Them All after all.
I'm finding I feel less and less of FOMO as the idea that some piece of clothing is so important isn't working for me. For me, I think it's about how you wear your clothing, the energy you project. The reverse of the old "When you look good, you feel good." I think when you feel good - or even recall what it feels like to have felt good! - you look good. And most people don't want to do a lot of thinking so if you project that you feel/look good, they're likely to pick up on that and agree.

I'm in a psychological position where I think the most useful function of clothing is not to broadcast your "brand" - what you want people to think about you - but to approximate what people you want to join are wearing. I got this idea from one of Edith Head's books and it makes total sense to me. At the same time, I don't often need to do that and tend to think of clothing cinematically, as perhaps a romantic and adventurous protagonist. So when I try something on, in that cramped, ill lit space with the distorted mirror, what I see in my mind's eye is myself striding across a wide screen.

Sarah, you are singing my tune! I have been a dedicated thrifter since my college days, for all the "pro" reasons you've listed. The cons you mention don't bother me much: no matter how much "churning" thrift-shopping results in (and it does create a lot of churn), it is still recycling, and it benefits charities while preventing boredom; the "ick" factor is quickly dealt with by an immediate laundering or trip to the cleaner. There is one reason why many women may have not have the best luck at thrift shops: size. Women on the shorter and/or slimmer side will find more merchandise that fits for the simple reasons that clothes shrink when cleaned, and women donate clothes they "grow out of". I hunt in secondhand shops for both my daughters, the elder of whom is average height, size 2-6; the younger is taller and broad in the shoulders, with long legs and a large bust. I have found countless beautiful vintage and designer pieces for elder daughter, but almost nothing for my younger girl: the larger-sized items were scarce, much more worn, and matronly looking. As my own body has thickened over time, I no longer find as much that suits me as I did when I was a slim petite. But I still enjoy the hunt--very important!--and shop as much or more for vintage/antique housewares as I do for clothes. One aspect of thrifting that is important for me (I mentioned it in another thread recently) is the opportunity it provides for inexpensive experimentation. When a new trend interests me, I will often hunt for the elements of that look in a good secondhand shop. (Because every fashion trend comes around, you may actually find more high-necked blouses, midi skirts, or wide silky pants there than in local department stores.) When I find pieces that create the trending silhouette, I take them home to test-wear for awhile. If I feel comfortable with them, I'll keep them and add more--old and new. If I decide that the look is not for me, it's no big deal--I donate the stuff again. When shopping experimentally, it's important to look outside your usual section; you may find the perfect oversized cashmere sweater in the Men's area, or a cropped blazer on the Boys' rack. Finally, for Jenn and others who just can't get into the thrill of the hunt or past the "ick" factor, I would say, don't push yourself. Thrifting is not everyone's cup of tea, but for those with plenty of time and an eye for quality, it can be extremely rewarding.

I really like shopping second hand, mostly to find fun and quirky accessories. I have been shopping second hand my entire adult life. Style wise, I love the mix of new and old and I am truly happy about outfits which contain some element of fun. Such fun items come often from second hand shops - brooches, scarves, handbags, gloves etc. I also love pieces which have some history and some narrative, a nostalgic, romantic vibe. It appeals to me. And I love the hunt. I do not mind that the shops often are not so well organized and one has to search through piles of stuff to find the hidden treasures. I actually find it very therapeutic. I enjoy going to second hand shops sometimes on the weekend, dive in, and "the world no longer exists" We have also a couple of great consignment shops in the neighbourhood, which are very enjoyable and carry more high end brands. I have not been shopping second hand online though - it is not the same thing to me.

As has been discussed on the Forum already, the quality of items has generally been declining for various reasons, and it is difficult to find the quality at mid-price range which has been common for 20 or more years ago. This is another reason which makes second hand finds often soo exciting. Well, I could go on and on about the pros, but they have already been mentioned.

As for the "ick factor" - I do not buy things which I cannot clean directly when I get home. Exceptionally, I get dry clean only-things - and they go directly to the dry cleaners'. These have to be real finds though, so the cleaning cost will be worth it.

I do like second-hand shopping. It's fun to discover treasures for a fraction of their original price. I can often find my favorite labels, and colors that I'm in love with, but aren't available in the current season.

We have a local thrift store that I visit a few times a year, and I've found a few favorite things. I've also found some great things on thredUp.com and I keep an eye out there for more. I like that I can heart things and then go back "shopping" later when I've had time to think them over and decide if I really need them. I've found the descriptions to be accurate when they say something is like new, and some things even still have the tags which is nice.

Caveats:

  • Sometimes I buy something I love, and then I get it home and notice a flaw. Usually it's not fatal, but even when it is, it's usually around $6.00 so I don't feel too badly about it. I've definitely regretted things I didn't buy far more than things I did. My goal this year is to really take time to inspect things better before purchasing them.
  • And I rarely have much luck if I'm looking for something specific. That requires a lot of patience as it may take months (or longer) for something that fits that particular need to show up. It's more of a place to browse and find a nice surprise.

Honestly, second-hand shopping has saved our budget over the past year. I've gone down a size every month or so, and have had to replace everything in my closet a few times over. I just had a terrible time justifying paying full-price for something that I would only be able to wear for a few weeks. I've also been able to experiment with different looks without losing too much money on styles that just didn't quite work out for me in the end (as several others mentioned).

As far as the ethics go, I have to admit I like the thought of things being worn out before they're discarded. I think I inherited it from my grandmother, who used clothing until it was worn out, then made quilts out of the bits that were still good cloth, and cleaning rags from the bits that weren't. I don't take it quite that far, but she definitely rubbed off on me.

And for the ick factor, I definitely wash everything, but like others have said, I grew up wearing the most amazing hand-me-downs, so I'm not really bothered wearing things that someone has worn before. Except underwear and swimsuits. I definitely draw the line there.

Great thread. I try to treat shopping at my favorite consignment shop, which is fairly selective in its merchandise, just like shopping anywhere else: only buy what I truly love and need. Although I probably buy something only once every few months (and pop in almost every weekend during strolls in my neighborhood), I’ve found some wonderful treasures over the years.