You've had great feedback, already, Suz, but I wanted to chime in and say --- absolutely, yes! Love these looks, and both sandals. The only question I have is do you want both to be in nude? The answer may well be, "sure," I just know that I"m mulling this over myself at the moment ---- do I want more color in my summer shoes, or the elegant, leg lengthening neutral?

Well, I don't have much to add except to say that you look FABULOUS! In every picture! I love the top, love every way you've paired it, and the shoes are beautiful - my favs are the SE's.

Beth Ann, that's a question I have, too. A bright sandal could be really fun. Except I bought one last year and almost never wore it. Largely because it wasn't as comfortable as I expected it to be or as flattering....but still. I am a bit wary now. My main concern with the Clark's is clunkiness, really. Hmmm. Still thinking on those.

Suz, sorry I'm late chiming in.....the cobalt looks amazing on you. I love how you paired it with white, very fresh for spring and summer. Is this the same sweater Sveta posted? Yours looks like true cobalt. FWIW, I like both pairs o shoes. One is chunkier and more casual and the other is a dressier sandal. They are both versatile because of colour and they both elongate the line of the leg. I vote keep both.

Ok I restrained myself and read the comments first, but I then returned to my first impulse, which was to look at each picture and scream at screen Suz KEEP! The cobalt blue sweater looks wonderful on you and I like both sandals too. The clarks look a bit more comfortable for moving around and the SE's a bit more dressy for different events but they both truly look fab on you. And all the cobalt is incredible on you with the white jeans and the skirt. So KEEP!

Suz, this blue color is incredible on you - not too intense at all. You really come alive in this color. Actually this is not that strange that this color suits you perfectly but just 'meh' for me as out coloring is so different.
Saying that I have decided to return all Gap sweaters. I cannot stand them being stretched out. I pulled on the hem a couple of times and it was noticeably stretched - too much for my liking.
I like both pairs of sandals and if you live in the summer it makes perfect sense to stock up - after all 3 months is 1/4 of the year - the whole season.
I looked at those SE sandals and was afraid the foot will slip too far in the front while walking because the toe opening is quite big. But if the are comfortable to walk in than keep for sure!

Cobalt sweater...Keep and get a backup while you can. Yes, it looks good with the VC skirt.
Sandals...I like the SEs best but only if they will be comfortable.

Whoa! That cobalt would be so much color for me, too! But it looks so good on you, I think bolder colours are waisting their force (or look the most appropiate for us blondes) when paired with some crisp whites-like you did so well here.
I wear today a bold fuchsia-purpleish denim jacket(see my post in Movie Posters Challenge/2 if interrested) and I was thinking about it, the same, at first. Then, it felt quite right with some whites and greys.
Love both your sandals, pls. keep all the lot!
ETA: I initially tought you are going to post this for Ornella's challenge day2(Stars War), as find it perfectly appropiate for that! :-))

Coming in late here (again). Keep the cobalt sweater, it looks amazing. But I wouldn't pair it with the skirt because of the cut: How would it look tucked? Although pic 14 is interesting and would certainly work. I love both sandals, the Suttons being my favourite, but won't they hurt your feet if they are too small? Pay attention to that bottom top strap. The Clarks: I have a similar pair from last year (with denim/leather on top instead of silver), wore them all summer. Not clunky at all, and great for wearing shorts, ankle pants or sporty skirts. But they will absolutely stretch. If they are already too big, that may be an issue. I asked a cobbler if it could be fixed but they said no. I ended up padding the soles of mine with insoles and it made it better... however I am not sure if they will be wearable this year! When they are too big, they impede your step, forcing you to walk a certain way, (subtle, but still), which cancels out any benefit you have from them being "Clarks".

That is a really pretty shade of blue. I really like both sandals. Even though they have ankle straps they don't break up your leg line, which is a major win in my book. I hope that the sizing works out for you.

Krish, my thoughts exactly...the back strap is also a bit loose on me. That might be helped with some velcro replacement. Well, I still have a few days to consider and have ordered a size up on the Pettys for comparison. Thank you all again.

Lyn - - I thought the same about the Star Wars! You will see soon. Off to check out your fuchsia!

You don't need this answer, but hi!

Cobalt is one of my favorite colors, so this would be a no brainer for me! It looks beautiful. I'm already past sweater weather and have other priorities or I'd be really tempted.