Janet, I have not seen the pictures, but if this is not perfect, please wait until you find the perfect one. Like you, I LOVE blackwatch tartan - but I think with something that is likely to be an item in my wardrobe for 10 - 20 years, it needs to be perfect. From your comments, this sounds close but not quite right.

I saw that Brooks Brothers also did a nice blackwatch tartan coat...

Oh wow! The smaller size became available! Will post pics when it arrives.

Looking forward to seeing your pictures of the smaller size.