Love. The. Sweater. I love all the looks but think it looks best paired with the slimmer bottoms. Great find. I want one.

Fabulous, keep, keep keep it

I may be too late, but I vote keep with the current size. It looks delibrately oversize, but still gives a nice shape because it has a lovely drape to it. And I like how you've already styled it here. A nice find!

I'd really love it in a size down I think. The entire vibe of the sweater is beautiful on you but I find it overwhelms you just a bit. The side view also gave me pause...but then I combat that with my apple belly so perhaps it is just against what I try to do for myself and not your look afterall. Beautiful sweater Susan.

Did you talk to them Suz? Any updates for us?

Yes, I keep checking for updates too. Inquiring minds want to know! It's a gorgeous sweater, and S is my size. I wish they'd put it on sale again!

I think Suz said she is travelling today, she's probably on the train! I am sure she'll update when she gets to her mum's.

Another vote for Keep! I like the fluidity on you and think the sweater works with all the bottoms. I actually like it best without the white shirt showing since that seems to take attention away from the drape of the sweater. I would not size down

Ceit's right. I'm on the road today. Will give them a call as soon as I can and update then. Thank you!

Also waiting to see if the XS is coming your way – I love, LOVE the sporty look of this sweater... on the website they also had listed and XXS but, all sold out except in the acorn color.

I'm surprised to like the volume on volume the best.