Keep!

I think the fit is perfect, definitely keep--they look great on you.

I am so envious! Those are perfect on you, and they are the same ones I really wanted. On me they are way too long. The released hem is fab. I vote keep.

I think these look absolutely amazing. I don't think that the thigh is too baggy. It looks relaxed to me but not baggy.

Brooklyn, are these TTS? I'd like a pair of straight crops that are not skin tight.

Viva, they are a size 29, which is the size I always take in Rag and Bone and in AGs. Often I am a 28 in non premium brands. I am a US size 6. My feeling is premium brands run small but that may just be my vanity talking.

Thanks Brooklyn. Seems we are close to the same size.

They look amazing on you. I love love love outfits 2 and 3 especially, for the reasons Sally voiced. I like the first outfit, too, but I just think the shorter top works a bit better, plus your choice of footwear for those is superb. It sounds as if you're inclined to keep, which is great!

I love them, as well as all three outfits you put together, and would like to steal the first in particular right out of your closet Keepers imo!

They look great on you and I love what you have paired them with.

Thanks again to everyone who chimed in on this post. And thanks to Lisa for that article on cropped wide legs. That makes me feel better about the roominess of these jeans. I was worried about them becoming orphans and have changed my mind about keeping them about 4 times since my initial post. But, after a marathon trying on session last night, I have "finally"
settled on keeping them. They feel fresh and fun. Will hopefully be wearing them this weekend. Thanks for the help!