JenniNZ, the tops were definitely different colors. The GH is a burnt orange, and the Poetry is a dark copper. I liked both colors, and either would work with my wardrobe, but the GH one was an absolute no-go. Have you ever gone to take a top off and had that moment where you're not sure it will go over your shoulders, and you might be stuck with it halfway off for the rest of your natural life? Yeah.
Ryce, good to know that the static problem might just stick around forever. That makes the decision easier.
LP, I keep at it because the winners I've gotten from them have been absolute workhorses. It's interesting that both you and KM received shipping refunds after posting reviews. That's worth a shot, even if it's not something to be expected.
Firecracker, I am too squeamish about the silk quality to keep, I think. The silk tunics I bought a few years ago looked great, but I kept them despite reservations about quality and regretted it when they developed runs and tears after 10-15 wears. Just not worth it.