I haven't looked at Fluevog for a while. My gmail seems to think their emails are spam so I almost never see them in my inbox. I've always run hot and cold on their styles - I either love them for their weirdness or think they are super ugly - so I think your response is normal. You know, I'd start to worry if I didn't get some kind of visceral love-it-or-hate-it reaction from Fluevog, because then I'd think they were slipping. (Kinda like allsaints these days, most of it is just meh, when in the past it was all weird-ugly or weird-fantastic.)
Both my pairs are quite old - I have red Operetta booties and the navy Dankes that I bought from Janet.