I have actually tried this little website and to be honest, I'm still not sure how I feel about it all...
I LOVE how the website is set up for the most part. A few things I would love to see added are an option to look at only items that are new with tags, I'd love to see an accessories tab, and I'd love to be able to look at only the new items added each day.
I have had 50/50 success with buying from them so far. I have gotten several blouses that were somehow really stretched out on the lower half of the blouse to the point that they looked like they were made for maternity instead but these are brands that are not known for making maternity items so I'm still trying to figure that out... (I've had a few items I got like this but I loved the overall make of them so much that I kept them and had them altered - ONLY TWO.) In addition, I've gotten several items that felt as though they must have been run through the laundry and shrunk in size and that was why someone else was selling them - because they no longer fit true to size. That is pretty frustrating to say the least. Yes, they do have the measurements listed but when a 4p always fits me at Ann Taylor Loft, then I don't expect to have to check that each time. So far, with every order I've made, I have returned at least half of the items for mostly tight fit and a few for being stretched out.
Overall, they have pretty great product - you just really need to be on top of your game and make sure you know what you're getting before you put it in that shopping cart and hit process order.
Selling to them was a completely different experience. I will try them one more time but I was not so impressed the first time around. The first time around, I sent all items that had been bought at major department stores and were of Ann Taylor / Banana Republic caliber. I sent an accessory from Ann Taylor that was new with tags and roughly $35 when I bought it (holiday sash) and they didn't even take it. Now it is gone and I can't even get any money out of it by possibly sending it to Thredup.com instead... (They are much bigger and thereby, much slower in their processing and they don't always give you as much money per item but they do take more items and they take accessories.) In addition to this, I sent in roughly 25 items and almost all were rejected with exception of four - either for unaccepted brand (one), or for "dated" (mind you, all of the items I sent were either items I had bought in the past two years or had seen on their site to begin with and expected they would be accepted). The ones that really got me the most were three different sleeveless dresses I had seen on their site not just the week before. One was a plaid dress from American Eagle, another was a holiday dress from Ann Taylor, and the third was Banana Republic - a white eyelet dress. All three of those were rejected and yet, the same ones were on the site. I take quite good care of my clothes so I'm not sure what happened there but I was a little frustrated with it to say the least.
I am going to try them one more time and we'll see how well it does the second time around... I do wish I had not sent so many items all at once. This time, I am just sending a few. I am also sending back a few items that are not considered "returnable" because I bought them on a 40% discount but the items themselves weren't on clearance per se so we will see if they get accepted.
I no longer live close to the really great consignment shops of Tennessee so this is my best bet at the moment... Hope that gives you a better idea.