These are great and very tomboy with a twist - I say keep!

Ooh, I cannot wait until tomorrow to compare shoes and decide!!

Tina, I wear I size 8.5-9.... more often 9 now that I've been doing retail a while. The oxfords I got in 39. I'm also 5'4" so sometimes my feet seem bigger because of my height. :T

Thanks Rae, that is perfect to know. They actually look surprisingly tiny for 39s, they look great on you.

My MIL is 5'4 and she wears an 11-12, OMG. That is why my nine year old son wears a men's size nine. My feet look comparatively small next to all of theirs.

I think those oxfords are giving me palpitations. You must keep them.

I love them but I am also kind of loving the raffia sneakers!

These look great with all of your outfits - I really love them, and am considering spending some of my Christmas money on them! However, I do really love the look of the rafia sneakers too - and can't wait to see what they look like on your feet and hear how they feel on your feet! My oh my - if they both worked for me, I'd be tempted (if I could afford it) to get both and use them as my summer staple shoes all spring and summer long!

Not looking at responses yet. I was so-so on the galaxy boot, but love the oxford version! Keep!

While the rafia sneaks and dansko are interesting the galaxy oxfords have that not going to find anything cooler than these look (to me at least)....

ETA: Is there an easy way to navigate the Solestruck website by heel height?

I'm holding until I can see all three compared.

I do like the way these look with the bf outfit and the longer skirt.