I like them on you, they are very flattering, and like the combos with the BCBG and white tops the best. The two-toned/re-done denim is supposed to big this season. I tried them too and liked them but at at the end went with a similar pair from Express as the rise on the Gap version was a bit too low for me.

I really like them they are interesting and very flattering on you.I like them with the BCBG top. The black jacket and booties is my fave pic.I think KEEP !

I love these on you!

Thanks for the feedback! Tanya, interesting that Express is offering very nearly the same style! Of course, if a rise is too low for you, it's probably just enough mid rise for me. I sometimes wish I could go back in time and have the spinal surgery to correct my scoliosis -- I probably would have ended up 5'8" or 5'9" and with the extra inch or two in my torso!

Killer.

LOVE.

Especially love #1, #7, #9 and #11.

Thank you for chiming in, Angie!

For the price I paid for these (on sale, plus a coupon), I think I can justify keeping some trendy denim to kick up my collection for the next few seasons.

Thank you all for the feedback!

I really like these on you. Very flattering and I like the tops you chose.

I like them. Especially with the patterned jacket.

I'm loving #1 and #7. I agree that they aren't the most versatile but they're fun and different for those of us who live in jeans. They're on super markdown at Gap Canada so I imagine you got that same great price......so, I'd say a great buy.

How did you find the sizing?

Edit.....They're even cheaper in Canada! Marked down to $35.98

I think these look absolutely fantastic on you, Janet, and they are perfect for the arty-edgy side of your style persona!!

I actually ordered a similar pair from Gap yesterday, just before I saw your forum thread, and if they look even half as fantastic on me as yours then I'll be very happy

So good to see the thumbs up from Angie!

These jeans fit you perfectly and are very flattering on you!!!

I think they look lovely

I really like them on you. You have an amazing collection of lightweight coats which you can wear as toppers!

These are extremely flattering and you have a good eye as the lighter top is definitely the best look with them.

I really like them - flattering & different

You look fab in these jeans and I like all of the ways you styled them.

I didn't expect to like these jeans, but I have to say they look nice and different (in a good way). I especially love them with the basic light shirt (#1) and with the black coat and boots. They add some "spice" to these elegant minimal outfits.

Two-tone jeans must really be A Thing, as Top Shop/Nordstrom has them in addition to Gap and Express. All three places look like they have different rises, so there's a rise for everyone.

I'm glad you decided to keep them. I think it was a good decision.