I got my Frye Cindys a few days ago and got the chance to really try them on today. I really love the color and the slouch (unlike an earlier pair of boots I tried, these have the right circumference around my foot, even for a slouch boot there can be too much gaping, I think). I'm somewhat neutral on the toe--I would have preferred an almond toe, but this should be fine too. The one thing is that the boots are just slightly too big, at least with only one pair of socks...I can feel that they're too loose in the heel. I don't know if a heel insert would work for this, and it might be very hard to get in. But they're not too difficult to walk around in, but I probably should test this more. Zappos doesn't have a smaller size.