Thanks for the additional feedback - I agree that the extra length on the medium hangs better, making it more like a relaxed tunic than a too-short top. As for the white shirt underneath, that was just playing with proportions - same with layering a cardigan over the top. I think it's the long skirt that makes it look too staid - it might work better with the colourful pants or other 'fun' bottoms.
As for the voting, I guess it was more to see whether people think I should keep or return the tops (ie do they work on me or not at all)?
I know I don't look good in black near my face, but I needed some wardrobe staples & the only other colours they sell this top in are neon yellow & stripes. Pastels wash me out & neons make my tan look sour lol, so I think I'll stick with using a scarf to break up the colour of the tops.
It's good to finally have some light, soft summery tops that are work appropriate but still suit my style!