I really like all of these looks, except #10, in the original post, which strikes me as "governess-y". The white blouse underneath is taking away the playful feel of your top.

I prefer the medium in both of these tops, mainly because I feel the swingy, carefree feeling is lost with the shorter, smaller size. And I LOVE your combinations. The only outfit I dislike is the black top layered over the long sleeved white top. I think this asymmetric top is a very flattering and versatile look for you!

You ask us to vote Yay or Nay, but to what? Yay/Nay to flattering? Or Yay/Nay to frumpy? And concerning which picture? There are so incredibly many ...

Generally, I think the white top looks great on you, practically no matter how you style it. (I must admit, though, that in my opinion, the long necklace used in some of the pics gets in conflict with the asymmetric lines of the top and should be left out or substituted by a shorter necklace.)

Honestly, I don't think the black top does anything for you. If I were you, I would either keep the white one only or try to get another top in a lighter colour, i.e. peach or mint.

Thanks for the additional feedback - I agree that the extra length on the medium hangs better, making it more like a relaxed tunic than a too-short top. As for the white shirt underneath, that was just playing with proportions - same with layering a cardigan over the top. I think it's the long skirt that makes it look too staid - it might work better with the colourful pants or other 'fun' bottoms.

As for the voting, I guess it was more to see whether people think I should keep or return the tops (ie do they work on me or not at all)?

I know I don't look good in black near my face, but I needed some wardrobe staples & the only other colours they sell this top in are neon yellow & stripes. Pastels wash me out & neons make my tan look sour lol, so I think I'll stick with using a scarf to break up the colour of the tops.

It's good to finally have some light, soft summery tops that are work appropriate but still suit my style!