I think it is fabulous, particularly with the lighter colors like 5/6. I was also thinking that the shedding might be limited, but that would give me pause. Are there online reviews? Hard to judge the head to coat factor without the head - but it looks good to me.

Just voting "yes" again for the oversized look.

Have you tried running a lint roller on it to see how much comes off? Hopefully shedding is short-lived.

Sloper, the coat was delivered today and haven’t had the time to actually see how bad it sheds. I noticed it on a pair of wool black pants I tried it with. It’s like a kind of fluff that gets on top of black pants if worn with a light color cashmere sweater, I’m going to examine it tomorrow and run a lint brush over it.

I like it! I don't think it looks overwhelming. It looks intentionally oversized, not sloppy. The only thing that would bother me is the shedding. I once had a puffer that shed feathers, and I looked like I had been in a barn after I took my coat off, lol. But this is different from a puffer, obviously. I think that if you love the coat a lot, you'll find a way to deal with the shedding.

I love it and find that with faux fur the shedding stops. It is very luxe and I love the lighter colour for winter.

One more who loves it. Such a great color for you and delicious texture. I think the fit looks good.

Thanks, ladies for your support. It means a lot to me!

Update: I took the coat outside and shook it well. I rolled a lint brush over it after and found no fluff on a brush! I wore it with black jeans and had no issues. So, like many said, the fluff was there because the coat is new. So, that is sorted.
I still have doubts about the fit. The oversized style is not a problem for me, I rather like it. The problem with the fit is the shape and the length. It happens often when I buy a regular clothes, the widest (hips) part of the garment is below the wides part of my body by at least 5 inches. This creates folds as it can be seen on the buttoned coat in photos. And the length is also about 5 inches too long. Shortening might help with the shape but it will push the price point much higher since I also have to shorten sleeves, something that I have to do on all my coats. Winter outwear is a real challenge for me.
So, I don’t know - I really like the coat and hate the idea of letting it go. I love the color and texture, it fits my color palette, it’s a good quality brand that I can only afford at the sale price. Is it JFE and my expectations are unattainable giving my petite sizing?

That's a tough one. Alterations that take an item into a whole other price point are frustrating (this just happened to me with a pair of new sandals I took in to have a thicker rubber sole added - to the tune of $70.00).

Going back to the photos now to look at the length of the coat again...

I don't see it as being too long at all - but you are the one wearing it, so ...

Knowing how pristine and unRATEd you like your things to be, I expect you’d have to have this coat cleaned more frequently with a low hem. Paying for the alteration could save you that future expense.

I love the coat on you - happy the shedding is sorted .
What about the shortening only the sleeves - not the length of the coat? 
The slightly longer coat is something to get used to - could it work with current length?

Have you tried a sit test? I also have issues with width of the garment being too low for me. In my experience when there's folds when the garment is fastened, it will be ludicrous when I sit.

But I've also had success with moving the buttons on a coat. It took care of this issue and was not a discernable alteration.

Well I really liked the style of the coat on you from the start, but if you are not happy with the fit then send it back. Shortening the sleeves and the length will make a difference, but I don’t see how it would affect the overall shape of the coat. The widest part will still be well below your hip won’t it? Maybe I’ve misunderstood your concerns. If so, just ignore me

Missvee, I love this coat but I can see some fit issues. I’m trying to find out if this is me being a perfectionist or others can see it, too.Aiming for everything to be perfect is not the best attitude and it is something I struggle with often.

It doesn’t overwhelm you and I think it looks interesting, but not over-interesting, and certainly not blah.
I really like how you’ve styled it here.

In looking at the pics again (bearing in mind the fit issues you've just raised) I am thinking the widest part of the coat is where the side-seam pockets are placed? These are going to be lower than hip height for everyone (since they are meant to be able to readily access with hands), so I don't think it looks odd or like the coat is 5" too long on you. The overall length looks really luxurious and fab to me, similar to the Max Mara teddy coat (see pic).

If you lay the coat flat on its back, what does its shape look like? Normally cocoon coats are sort of egg-shaped, so the widest part is an incremental fullness through a large part of the body, rather than a jutting out at the hips (or below the hips, as yours is fitting you), if that makes any sense at all :). So my hunch is that the primary factor in what you're seeing is related to the side-seam pockets, not a bulging out below your hip because of the cocoon shape hitting you too low because of your height.

However...if you are genuinely not happy with the fit and you keep it, if you are anything like me the perceived fit issue will gnaw at you and lessen your enjoyment of the coat.

I struggle with this shape/style of coat too, and have been looking for the right one for a few years. The line between too-big-all-over and not-oversized-at-all is a very fine one when you’re borderline petite. My take is, if the cut is bothering you now it’s only going to bother you more in the long run. And it’s early enough in the season that other options will most likely turn up. I don’t know the Bay’s return policy; can you keep this one in the closet with tags on for a while so you can do side by side comparisons with other coats?

Ah, yes I see your point. Perhaps another way to look at it is to ask yourself which of your clothes are JFE, and whether these are items that you enjoy wearing. If they are, then maybe you just need time to get used to a new silhouette?

Another thing - have you checked out the cost of alterations? I had a faux fur coat shortened 2 years ago and it was close to $100Cdn. Plus I had to hunt for a tailor willing to do it because of the thickness of the fabric. And after all this effort, I still haven’t worn it..not even once. Hangs head…

I have about 30 days to return the coat. Thanks to your advices, I will let it stay for a while. I feel I need to step away and try again later to determine if the fit still bother me.
Jonesy, you are right, it is probably pockets.

Missvee, I’m waiting for my tailor to quote me on the price of sleeves shortening first. This is something I will definitely have to do if I keep it.

I love a faux fur because it is lightweight, isn't it! This one has a great cut in my opinion almost a barell and love how you styled it with lighter jeans but strong black accents, that cross body bag especially looks great, I say, KEEP as YLF in this!

Came back to say, I wouldn't shorten or take in -think it looks quite good length and shape, too-and you'll keep moving in it so nobody will stare and measure-but is important to feel fab, and trust our own eyes-and feelings-so maybe trying one size down?

It doesn’t look too long to me; but I see the width (or pocket?) silhouette you mention. Are you wanting a more a-line fit? You might be able to find it, bit maybe at the expense of accessible (and large) pockets. I’ve regretted buying coats with dainty, shallow pockets that don’t fit my gloved hands…

Agree with holding this one for a bit and taking another look in a week or two.

Add me to the LOVE column. I think it is a great color and looks amazing on you. I was wondering if the shedding would decrease so I'm happy that happened, white fuzz is quite annoying. I like the length, makes it feel more fun and oversized. I would make sure the pockets are accessible though.