OMG, Jacket #1 is phenomenal! I can't see past that. You must keep. LOVE it! And your hair is looking amazing!

My vote is definitely Jacket #1. It's flattering on you and it looks polished yet edgy.

My cardigan vote is the white one.

Jacket 1, cream cardigan.

I also would vote jacket 1 and cream cardi, but don't worry--your skin is glowing in the yellow and the color is very on trend. You probably have plenty of neutrals already. That jacket is wow!

Jacket #1 is extremely flattering on you, but I wonder if #2 is more your funky, cool, slouchy style? I would consider which is more important - attitude or hotness. (-:

I prefer the yellow cardi - I think it's a good color on you and more interesting than the cream... I usually prefer to see texture with a cream sweater for interest.

#1 jacket
both cardi.

#!!!!! YAY - you found it!!

ETA that was a vote for for 1.

I like the cream cardi better....also more versatile I think perhaps....

Thank you everyone for your opinions!

Now, for the details. Jacket #1 is from Zara. Jacket #2, Madewell. I liked the slouchy, soft leather of the Madewell jacket (which was double the price of the Zara jacket). It was slightly crinkly like a Muubaa jacket but not fitted. But not oversized either. The sleeves fit perfectly. I liked the length of the Medium better but the shoulders were too wide on me. The double breasted button style was tedious. I returned it, to the dismay of the Madewell store manager.

Thanks also for the votes on the cardi. I know cardis are not everyone's cup of tea, but I like them for my casual capsule, I like to be as comfortable as loungewear.

The first jacket is just amazing! And I prefer the yellow cardi, but you know I am a color girl so take it for what it's worth!

Love jacket #1! So you. Although I love the mustard yellow color, I think I prefer the cream cardi with your complexion.

Love the first one on you by far.

Late to respond but like jacket number 1 and cardi number 1 (white).

glad you got it. i tried that zara jacket. i almost bought it but i have way too any black leather jackets already!

you look soooooo fab in this. ii is really "denise"

late response and not looking at other's I'd say the first jacket because it looks good both open and closed, 2nd is great too, I just prefer it closed to open. Cardi I vote for is the lighter one, looks better with your coloring, but you said the hotel lighting was off, so that may be not the case....

I really like leather #1. I'm even on the cardies.

Well I'm late to the party but I sure hope you kept jacket #1 and the cream cardigan