Agree with the others who've said that it's the stylist that makes the biggest difference. And also that your particular hair will factor in. My own hair, which is thin, fine, and curly, isn't a very common type at all. I have had PLENTY of bad cuts, both expensive and inexpensive; most stylists just don't have experience with my hair type! When I find a stylist that does AND who gets my style desires? I hold onto them as long as possible!! With my short hair, I'm happily paying around $90 every 6 weeks or so to get it cut. I ADORE my current stylist, she really knows her stuff AND is experienced with my hair type. It is absolutely worth it to me. Like Angie, my hair is a HUGE part of my look and so getting the right cut is a priority that I budget for. When I wore my hair longer, I got it cut every few months (same price) because it didn't need to precision that a short cut does.
I quite like your salon cuts Natalie, especially #5/6! The bangs and feathered ends are really nicely done. Plus I think the layering really does make a difference in the overall look. And hey if hubby likes the salon look, who's to argue?