Good question, Vicki. I wasn't looking for the cashmere. I was looking for linen sweaters or tops for this season -- we are just moving into summer here. But I just happened to see the cashmere while I was on the website, and it was at a good price (especially for a Collection sweater), in one of my best colours, PLUS I had a gift card.
In February I got another oversized J. Crew collection cashmere sweater in a heavier gauge knit and I literally wore it almost every single day until mid-April. It was that cozy and wonderful. (I wore it as regular work at home wear AND as lounge wear.) So I knew that a lighter weight one in a good colour for me would be a real keeper.
I guess I'm always keeping in mind what items have been complete and utter workhorses for me from the get-go. When I find something like that, I am more likely to buy a similar item during the off-season, secure in the knowledge that it will definitely get worn.