What a fun thread!!
I do remember a few of my 90s shoes. At the end of the 80s and early in the 90s, I wore Docs, which I loved. Mine were monk-strap brogues in black. Adored those shoes; I had a couple of different iterations of them. I also had a pair of lace up granny type booties (also black...hmmmm, Angie, I don't LOVE black shoes, honest -- it's just that they are practical!!). And I almost always have some type of chelsea boot and I'm sure I did then. This was also when I started wearing Blundstones. More love.
My dressy shoes (that I recall) were a really fun pair of Mary Janes that were reminiscent (to me) of the 20s -- they had a Louis heel that I loved. And a slightly squared off toe, but delicate. And they were charcoal grey, not black.