DJP-
So fun to read your analysis. I've ordered those 424s already and it's nice to get your take on the quality and heel height (the latter is not mentioned in the write up in the Bay's website).
I liked the almond toe but think I prefer the toe on the Seychelles more, so I ordered both to compare.
I did review the Vince Camuto and agree that they're indeed more refined with their pointy toe but it's the slightly western heel that I'm less keen on (I just have a personal preference for a straighter heel).
Also, about the size, I sized up to an 8.5/39 but my feet can fit a 38 if the toe is not too pointy. ...They might be just the right size if you say they fit small.
It doesn't rain as much here as it does in Vancouver, plus The season for these in eastern Canada is short, so I'm not *that* concerned about wear.
Kiwi, I am excited to hear about your good experience with camel. I love this colour! We are fellow Kibbe Naturals I think.