Without being influenced by others' comments, I like the Paiges on you best. I prefer the narrower bottom - and think they are ultra-flattering on you. Now that said, the first pair fit you equally well, and are also flattering - it's just the leg opening that looks more "traditional" and less fashiony. To me, burgundy can look preppy and traditional and to make it look modern and new, it needs to be in a silhouette that is also more modern. Unless of course none of that matters to you
Can't really see much of the detail of the Costco pants - but funny the things that happen on the way to the seafood counter. I usually get usurped by DH throwing in random electronics and game controllers when I'm not looking. "Oh the one I had isn't working any more". As if I would know the difference or even know he had one to begin with.