I love the cerulean on you as well as the color in the original photo. Although I have darker skin, I follow the rules of a Winter, too. The color palates that others have posted were a big help to me in the past; even though I don't love bright colors in outside of my office, I was able to pick and choose the darker colors that flattered AND appealed to me... so I guess my point is you don't have to wear any color just because it's your season... take what you like and leave the rest.
IMO, makeup is overrated. Most days, I go out only in blush and chapstick. I think I read somewhere that blush is the most important thing for Winters, although I can't remember why. It looks like you have very nice skin, so you don't need to wear makeup unless you want to.
P.S. Nice job on the Photoshop - what a great tool!