Oh yes, my mother does it in a very demeaning way. I know she does not mean to do so. But the fact remains that she's being critical of the person she is looking at. She puts too much importance on people's appearance, and is not tactful when she thinks someone is poorly dressed, overweight, or "could do better". The fact that she'll be 80, and has poor hearing exacerbates the problem. She will say things she shouldn't say, and does not realize the people she is talking about CAN hear her.

A few of my sister's are quite overweight, and it seems to be my mother's favorite topic some days. I know she talks about me to my other sisters the same way she talks about them to me. It's actually become a family joke. Unfortunately, for my heavy sisters, it's painful. Ah, the joys of coming from a big family! The bigger the family, the more disfunction there is to go around!

I just found this great topic. It was so much fun reading all of your stories! Interestingly enough, not too many people at school have complemented me on my new look. The people that have noticed most are my voice teacher and my mom; at least they are the ones always saying I look nice. The head of the music department complemented me on my new hair style, and usually says he likes my hats (something that I've worn for several years, even though I don't think I've posted a picture of any of them here yet... need to do that). Yesterday one of my voice students said she liked my Sweet Pea top. Thanks to Tanya for posting the link here. She dresses very artsy, so that complement felt great to me. I'm afraid I do get more of the snide remarks, but I try to take those as complements too. After reading this thread I want to give more complements.

Oh, this is the thread I've been looking for, about "the compliment that isn't" - thanks to Sarah for bringing it to the surface!