I love #3 but if the fit is off (& can't be fixed) then the other two are fab.

Oh I can't even tally up which one is in the lead but I guess #3 seems to be the frontrunner, and then a split between #1 and 2, perhaps?

You rock the frock! I honestly love them all but have a preference for 1 and 2. #1 is just drop dead gorgeous. #2 is fun and a different silhouette. I really love that one--and that was my least fave on Angie's dress post. You have some tough decisions ahead of you!

I'm going to vote for #2 and #3. I think #2 is going to be an extremely versatile dress, while #3 is an oustanding color and such an amazing statement piece. All three of them look absolutely lovely on you, though.

Wow, the zebra is my favorite for sure. But just because we have to choose. Really they are all gorgeous and I love your pointy red shoes!

Queen Dress never lets us down!!

They are all an 11 out of 10. Can't go wrong with whichever you decide to keep you gorgeous lady

And yup, I feel a fainting spell coming along.

*faints*

Angie! Revive yourself!

*sighs* If only I were there to bring you a cup of tea.

Failing that, I guess it's up to me. Plan A is that I'm going to Nordstrom tomorrow to size up on the mint dress. If I can get it to work, I'm keeping that, and the zebra, which I will wear with a jacket for work. Plan B is if I can't get the mint to work, I get the zebra and the stripe.

THANK you all for the wonderful help!! (I was going to return the mint dress until your comments persuaded me otherwise).

These all look great, but PLEASE, PLEASE, PLEASE keep the zebra!

Yay -- you're keeping the zebra!

This so difficult Laura, as they all look stunning on you. Can't you keep all three? If one really must go back, I vote the striped one.

Love the Zebra dress

Laura, I'm late to this but my vote is for 1 & 3, they are both fabulous. 2 is cute but it reads a little juvenile to me, it's not quite the sophisticated look of the other two dresses but this is just MHO:)

Oh, now there is a wrench thrown into the works. Last night I received an invitation to my high school reunion in August. It is CASUAL and I mean casual. The striped dress with fun red sandals might be the ideal outfit, because as Deborah says it might be a little less sophisticated than the others -- but that is perfect for this reunion.

What do you think? Should I keep all three?

I love (and want) them all!:-)
Zebra is very formal to my eye, striped is so chic, and perfect for casuals-too, and I say mint is quite different to your cobalt one, as more springy, to me.
Can you keep them all?

They all look wonderful on you, but I'm leaning toward 2 and 3.

Yes, I think you should keep all three! I do love that zebra print on you as well - but when forced to try and choose, I thought the striped one might be more versatile and 'fun' in terms of a more casual-ish spring/summer type dress. Red sandals with it at a casual reunion sounds fabulous.

Very excited that you're keeping all three!

Laura - if it works in the budget, why not keep all three? They will all work beautifully for you and I love the idea of the striped fit and flare for the reunion.