Now ad-free for everyone!

Please consider supporting us by becoming a patron for $8.00 per month, or a non-recurring annual contribution of $96.00.


Monthly contributions can be canceled at any time.

2020 Footwear And Bags Returned

Collection by Chris987

Vanilla Eccos - too cool a color to fit easily into my wardrobe. Sofft Cork sandals (no find) when trying them on at home my big toe hangs off the edge just a little. Vagabond off white sneaker - 38 was too big in the toe box and chose a different style for this general color. Yellow flats - just didn't love them and also no support at all although an insert would have fixed that.. Green Vagabonds in 37 - too cool a color. and the 37 is just a little too small - big toe hits the front. Vionic olive sneaker - size 7 fits well overall and the arch is NOT too high, but big toe bumps into front. Naturalizer Sandal in "nude suede" is blush, not tan; 6.5 is a bit snug but probably the right size for sandals. The bearpaw sneakers uppers were too soft and unsupportive and the laces were really difficult to tighten. Straw round bag - a little too small and didn’t like it IRL as much as I liked the idea. Black slingback espadrilles - look chunky on foot, and the opening rubs on my big toe. The brown espadrilles with sling back are too loose around the heel and not adjustable. CK tan crossbody just a hair too small. Clark blush sandals feel good overall but too loose and sloppy in the toe and instep area and not adjustable. Eric Michael espadrilles were frayed at the toe/jute area, synthetic "vinyl" feeling sock liner, no arch support, cut into my foot in various places. 37 seemed the right size but toes crowded a little. White DKNY cross body - a little smaller than measurements given and a bit too small to work. The tan Benissa sandal was too cool a color to go with the rest of my warm browns; was really obvious when I opened them up. Black Clark loafers were comfy and fit well, just too boring. Clark Leopard booties were very comfy, size 7 fit well with socks, but they rubbed on my ankle bone. The Born black booties were too big in a 7.5 even with inserts added, decided I want something lighter weight for indoors. Clark booties size 7 was a bit too snug for socks and the 7.5 is too big plus inserts don't work right. The Madewell dark brown booties in a 7.5 were too big even with an insert added...too long. Otherwise seemed ok, could try 7. Lucky Imali boots too loose at heel, a bit snug at front, WITH insole added. Also a bit heavy at 1lb 3oz per boot. The All-black "shooties" were amazingly comfortable with wool socks in a size 7.5, but did not like the way they looked. The Mark Fisher black boots had a bright red/pink stripe up the back, and same color stitching around the sole. NOT as shown and did not like. Also a sole this thick (platform is 1") looked way too clunky, 7.5 was too big, go with 7 if try this brand again

Madewell Madewell
View Info
Top Pick