Now ad-free for everyone!

Please consider supporting us by becoming a patron for $8.00 per month, or a non-recurring annual contribution of $96.00.

Contribute

Monthly contributions can be canceled at any time.

2026 footwear rejected

Collection by Chris987

Comfortiva Carver: 7.5 good, not enough sole cushioning and too narrow ball of foot. Vionic Carissa 7.5 big with medium weight wool socks, don't like enough to experiment with additional insoles. Dansko Faithe 7.5 ok but square toe and heel not refined. Sofft Bridget too chunky not refined enough. Vaneli Elide 7.5 good but soles way too thin. Orthofeet slippers don't quite feel right in 7.5 and velcro tab too fussy for slippers. Gentle souls Emily loafers 7 fit well but color too cool and could not find other colors. Forever & Always loafers too chunky and 7 too big but do consider brand again. Easy Spirit Vitalia 7 too snug across toe with insoles added to make heel fit well; oo boring. Kelsi dagger lens (DSW) heel loose 6.5 but toe too tight. Franco Sarto Senna 6.5 is close but little toe bone pinched on outside of foot and heel loose. Clark oronico 6.5 big toe hit front, heel fit great, but a bit too chunky. Nauralizer Shawna 7 too loose in heel, and too chunky. Clark Ayla patent loafer 6.5 too short, big toe hits front, 7 too short but heel slips. DKNY Civelli Loafer 7 too short and heel slipped. Sole surprisingly stiff so if try this brand again size up & try insole. Coach glazed penny loafers fit ok in 7 but square toe is super ugly. Vionic Cleo toe bumped front 6.5 otherwise fit well; 7 toe still hit but heel too loose. Clarks Calena in 7W is right size but strap has to be pulled so far over instep that it sticks out and looks awkward. Naturalizer Hattie 6.5 right size but too flimsy not comfortable or supportive. Sofft Nova 7 heel slipped toe area too short. Vionic Winny 7 fit ok, chose a diff one. Soft Nova, Eurosoft Lelea, FS a-saffron, and comfortiva Ester all had toe area fit well but heel slipped size 7. LIfestride London2 7 SO CLOSE, love the look, fit well, but ball of foot not cushioned enough.

Zappos
Dansko FaitheWomen's
View Info
Top Pick
0
Zappos
VANELi ElideWomen's
View Info
Top Pick
1
Zappos
Söfft NovaWomen's
View Info
Top Pick
0
Zappos
Eurosoft LeiaWomen's
View Info
Top Pick
0