Thanks, everybody! Wow, so interesting to see the range of opinions. Also interesting that everyone seems to like both of them, but the opinions on which one they like more are almost evenly divided.
I am hoping Angie chimes in, even though I know she's waiting for me to post some full length outfit pics. I probably won't have a chance to do that until Sunday.
I have a feeling that somehow the Leitmotiv one won't date so easily. The Zara one seems more trendy, even though I suspect both have some longevity as unique statement pieces. Mochi and Jules, I understand what you're saying about the Zara jacket -- it is definitely more of a "look" which doesn't bother me. It's a bit edgier and makes a bigger statement.
I suspect that the Zara might be a little less versatile for me, but I could be wrong. The color palette of the Zara jacket is a little more challenging for me to work with, since it's heavy on gold, but at least it's a soft gold. The Leitmotiv has more colors in it, and a quick glance in my closet tells me I have a few tops that would go with it, color wise.
It is worth noting that these two jackets have different seasonal use for me. The Leitmotiv one is so lightweight, I can wear it spring, summer, and fall. The Zara one will have to hibernate for the summer -- it's much too warm for our mid-Atlantic heat and humidity. The Leitmotiv one has enough room under it that I can layer a little more under it to take me well into fall.
Ideally, whatever jacket I get will work with jeans as well as skirts/dresses. I suspect that will depend on what tops I layer underneath. I wear jeans so much more than skirts and dresses. However, now that I'm thinking about it, in the summer I move towards my shorts and skirts more, as jeans are often too warm, and that changes the proportions I'd be working with. Hmm.
This is tough! I actually really like both of them. I wish I didn't have so much to do in the next two days -- I'm anxious to play around with these jackets!