Please, please keep both bags, Sveta. They are both stunning and completely fit your style!!

In this outfit I think both work equally well. The dove grey adds a lighter colour contrast, and the black with gold detailing subtle elegance.

What fantastic finds!!-)

Thank you all for your opinions. I am seriously leaning towards keeping both. My first thought was - why have 2 bags in the same style? Should I keep black and get dove in different style (Shannon's dome satchel is from the same series and comes in dove). Then I thought: "Wait a minute, you love the dove color IN this particular style, not just the color so another style would not be the same anyway" As for the black - this was the first black bag I got attracted to EVER and mostly because of the style and gold hardware - why look for a different black bag JUST for the sake of differences if I love this one? I also feel that being the same style they look pretty different because of the dramatic difference in color and different level of contrast with the hardware...different enough to play very different roles.
So I think I "almost" convinced myself. I am taking one of them for road test tomorrow and if it passes the practicality test I am keeping both!

Sveta, I am late to the bag party but FWIW I really like the dove one. The black disappears against your black pants which makes me think a bigger black bag might be an idea. Just a thought:)