Suz, I just saw this thread and wanted to weigh in. I like the first pic in the original set of pics, but was not convinced it looked consistent with what I know to be your current style. I could however, see you head in that direction.
The second pair of skirted leggings, reminds me too much of athletic wear. I may have poison eye for this from way too many early mornings wearing them myself as I headed out the door for my marathon training. Skirt Sports brand were about the only bottoms I wore, and I loved them in all legging lengths, summer and winter. No chafing, they are comfortable for running, they swish around, and even after 26.2 miles you look somewhat put together, etc. They were also great for after the run jaunts to the local diner for big breakfasts with my running friends. However, I somehow still see them as athletic gear, especially when the length of the skirt gets short. I hope you don't take this the wrong way, but the zipper in front reminds me of a reflective safety strip.