I am late to the dance to comment...Love the Target shirt..Envy..serious envy..your flannel shirt collection...I just love mine and it is so much fun to wear...I don't blame you for sending back the mismatched pattern..That my dear Nordies is just not acceptable...

Honestly, the two subdued, dark plaids are my favorite on you. Or perhaps you need to hold out for one that will make your eyes pop.

I would return it because you already have so many awesome plaids. Plus, I want that Target one -- really badly. I would have bought it too, AA be damned. In fact, I may have to make a Target run today. I think I need ... uh ... shampoo.

Hehe, Vivian -- glad to know I'm not alone. The first time I saw the Target plaid shirts, I took this picture because I liked the shirts so much -- the coordinating gingham accents (lining and elbow patches) are really cute too. The next time I was in Target, the supply had dwindled, so I hope you find your, um, shampoo!

I think you made the right decision Janet, the colours of the shirt are amazing but the mismatching leaves the eye with nowhere to rest.

I would return, that plaid not lining up would drive me nuts! And for the money you can do better...just my .02