One in one out: help me pick a shoe to eliminate

Yesterday I posted three pairs of new shoes. In order to accommodate them I need to eliminate three pairs from my existing collection. I sent a pair of Blondo boots and a pair of Beautifeel shoes to the giveaway pile before I went shopping and they were removed from the house already before I could take a pic. I still need to pick one more shoe.

I am thinking of picking one of my sneakers. I wore my new blue Candace Cooper sneakers and white perforated Via Spiga sneakers more than any other so far this year. My brown croc Finn Comforts come in next. That leaves the Taos gold leather sneakers and the Converse. I have another pair of converse somewhere, but they are not pictured and also not high tops. The converse are the least comfortable, maybe followed by the Finn Comforts even though I wear them (I like how they look so I sacrifice comfort).

I'm not sure which one should go? Tough choice for me here. I just know the Candace Coopers and Via Spigas stay.

This post has 1 photo. Photos uploaded by this member are only visible to other logged in members.

If you aren't a member, but would like to participate, please consider signing up. It only takes a minute and we'd love to have you.

8 years ago

Janet

(website)

Veteran

Of the ones pictured, I'm feeling the black (?) ones in the lower left corner the least for you. The gold ones look much more like they work with your wardrobe and your coloring.

Cerinda

Comfort argues sending both the Converse and the Finn Comforts on their way. Like Janet, I think the gold ones have great potential.

Angie

Fashion Stylist

Black sneakers.

deb

I agree, the black.

rachylou

Which are the most worn out?

catgirl

Oooh, I love the Missoni Converse! I agree, the black is probably the least needed in a fun capsule like this. But comfort should come first.

Laura (rhubarbgirl)

I'd get rid of the most worn out first, or alternatively the least comfortable. Also, Cons will be much easier to replace should you want to than the other styles.

Sara L.

I say either the brown ones or the Cons since you have another pair somewhere.

Staysfit

The Brown Finns are the oldest and most worn out.

Marley

The dark ones in the bottom left hand corner!

CocoLion

Another vote for the dark ones in the lower left hand corner.

unfrumped

How do the black hightops really look and work with your new palette and style? And they need to be really comfortable.

I finally realized that any sneakers need to be, well, really comfortable. Otherwise I usually would have enough options. For example, for me the Timberland hightops from NAS just did not fit my foot shape or arch and so I realized I did not want "fun" but not comfortable casual shoes.

Have been thinking about this more in anticipation of vacation capsule. It's harder than I thought to combine a "walking shoe" with some style goals. Making me think of looking outside the shoebox, IYKWIM!

Anonymous

I'm with Marley and CocoLion. Dark ones in the lower left. (brown? Black? Still adjusting to my new specs).

The lower left are the brown crocodile imprint Finn comforts.

Suz

Get rid of the Finns. (Uh, no offence to actual Finns, of course!)

Category