Natalie, big hugs! It is so frustrating when we feel we are striking out with shopping!
I actually think you are being really tough on yourself. I think the blue kimono is lovely on you -- but I also understand that you have to "feel" it. I returned mine because I didn't think it would get enough wear to justify the cost and even though I may not have LOOKED swamped, I felt swamped.
I wonder if that is what is happening with you and the BFs? I actually find them more flattering on you than skinnies, to be completely frank. But then, you must keep my style preferences in mind (and take with a grain of salt) because like Angie, I tend to prefer the look of a looser fit or looser tailored fit. On the whole. (Laughing to myself because I certainly do wear my body con VC skirts often enough to put the lie to that idea!)
Anyway...I love the crossover blouse on you! I am wondering if a little fashion magjc such as what Angie performed in her blog post might fix it for you. That might not be possible due to the fabrication. But it looks really pretty.
I think I'm with you about the jacket, though. The fit doesn't seem quite right and the colour isn't as good on you as the others, from what I can tell. If it wouldn't be comfortable, back it goes.