K/R: Pick two Vince Camuto midi skirt patterns!

Here are four patterns from the Vince Camuto midi skirts. I am thinking of keeping 2, since they're 2 for $79. I have a black one already. These are all size M. Does this look like the right size? Let me know what you think of the sweater and leggings too. Thanks in advance!
1-2 thick black and white stripes
3-4 black with thin white stripes
5-6 grey with black lace
7-8 black with white animal print spots
Full disclosure, I do have a white A line skirt with similar pattern to the lace one, and two Bobeau skirts with big polka dots. But I think I could still get plenty of wear out of these--I wear skirts all the time for both MOTG and work.
1-8. Trouve corrugated hi-low sweater in XS. The S was too baggy for my tastes. I think I'm keeping unless you hate it. I need more fluid drapey toppers.
9-10. Only Mine polka dot sweater in S. This is too small, I'm returning it, but I don't think I'll be ordering the M. I have too much polka dot stuff as it is, I don't think this will get enough wear to justify keeping.
11-12. Zella capri leggings and Lysse red leggings. Also there was a white pair of capri leggings that I forgot to take a pic of. These would mostly be for wearing with my turquoise Zella jacket (#11) and under dresses for MOTG (red and white, I already have black capri leggings).

This post has 12 photos. Photos uploaded by this member are only visible to other logged in members.

If you aren't a member, but would like to participate, please consider signing up. It only takes a minute and we'd love to have you.

10 years ago

Suz

(website)

Veteran

Tough to pick, Natalie! I like all the skirts. They do look like a good size for you. I would probably pick one strip and one of the other patterns -- I like the leopard/ dot one myself (though weirdly, I did not order it....go figure.)

I can't really see the details on the Trouve sweater, so if you love it, keep it.

Makes sense to return the ONly Mine dot.

Leggings look good on you. You have a lovely delicate calf and ankle.

Glory

This is a hard choice to be sure. I would agree with Suz to keep one stripy and I am leaning to the larger stripe and one of the other skirts. I like the dotted one myself but perhaps one would work better in your wardrobe than the other?

Vildy

My favorite on you is the strong graphic black and white stripe. Since you want 2, I vote for the other darker stripe. I think the stronger prints are more balancing of the top pieces. Love the coral leggings on you, too. You really do high contrast well! It loves you.

pil

Of the stripes, I prefer the bolder skirt in 1/2 because you can really pull off that graphic pattern. My other favorite is the spotted pattern. You sure look terrific in leggings!

rae

HM, I vote for the two stripes. They would be a nice offset to some polka dots! And even alone they still have kind of a Kate Spade vibe.

Have you tried on a size Small just for argument's sake? I prefer an XS for myself because the taper at the knee is more pronounced - and I think you're usually one size up from me in most things.

unfrumped

I also really like the bold stripe best. The smaller stripe reads more casual. The others are okay but not special, so unless you just need more options, you might hold out for something else, as this style seems to be picking up.

Category