I love the quality of Coach bags. However, I'm not too keen on the ones that are emblazoned with their logo all over. This may be personal taste - I really don't like obvious logos on anything. So I would not go for either of these bags - even the red one, that embossed pattern is their logo.
However, I WOULD go for the red "new embossed Ella." Gorgeous shade of red. The Garnet is nice too, if you prefer pebbled leather.
My girlfriend has the cambridge clutch in black - it's a lovely and versatile bag with lots of space for a clutch and many compartments to keep her organized. Too big for my body frame, but she's tall so she can handle it.