I just bought a couple pairs on sale, and I like them. I think they're good quality for the money (especially on sale!). I did find one that was a wool blend, but the synthetic blend ones are nice quality, too, and (bonus!) purportedly machine washable. I have a flat butt and small hips, though, but I did have to size down. I would try your regular size. Oh--not all of them fit exactly the same, of course, due to the drape of the fabric (despite all being "Editor"), so I wouldn't swear them off forever if you get a pair that doesn't work for you.