I wouldn't say there is a clear winner--I think both pairs look really great on you. My preference would be for the longer length, in part because you could add a heel to your look if you wanted (but I don't think they are too long for flats--they look good scrunched). The shorter length looks like it might be too short for anything but a flat.

Karlie, the photos are a bit hard to see on my monitor because of the dark bureau behind you. That said, it looks like both fit well through the hips, which is the crucial thing.

I really love them both. They both look great on your long slim legs, but if you absolutely have to choose, I would choose the narrower, longer pair, just to showcase your terrific limbs. But I do really love the almost straight pair too and think they look very chic.

You look great! I prefer the second pair, I like the way they scrunch.

I agree completely with Melanie... they both look great but the second ones accentuate your long lean limbs perfectly!!

I agree with the above, both are great but I like the longer so they can scrunch.

You look fantastic in skinnies! I like both on you equally well.

Hands down option #B. They look fantastic!

Thanks eveyone! I was leaning towards B, but it's good to know that either will work. Now I just need to figure out which size to keep; they stretched quite a bit just taking pictures yesterday. I"ll probably be posting later with a "are these too baggy" thread!