Thanks guys - here's my opinion.
I like the cut of the first one but I have been a bit uncertain if the colour is flattering. Jean, I would normally wear it with straight legs - good point.
i am kind of surprised about how boxy the second one is. I mostly wear it around the house like this http://i297.photobucket.com/al.....0_6919.jpg which I now see doesn't look that great (And I thought I looked good in short shorts - maybe not so much!)
I wore it with a white skirt immediately after having a baby, as well as about 6 months pregnant (I bought the first top as a non-maternity pregnancy top too, for mid-trimester)but I am not sure if I would like wearing voluminous tops with my denim skirt Inge. This top was only $5 so I can let go with little regret.