I love the pink one!

Pink - feels very joyful and fresh! You look great in both of course but navy dress is a bit more classic and serious .

Cannot believe my choice but I vote PINK.

Pink, and your hair is looking beautiful.

If not both, then pink for the win!

Pink - it lights you up.

The pink is a slam dunk. The navy looks nice but reads more basic/subdued. The pink is special.

I’m also going with pink! From the stock photo, would absolutely have said navy, but the actual pink on you is wonderfully 80s and likely more versatile than it might appear.

Pink! At least in the pictures, this particular shade of navy seems a bit lifeless on you. The pink is energizing and happy.

Thanks, everyone! Appreciate your thoughts. 

The votes are VERY strongly in favour of the PINK Fun! 

Sharan is 100%. For me and my style, the pink is as versatile as the navy since I remix clashing colours with ease. 

Inge, here is the first pic of the navy dress with pearls! It was before I ordered the pink. Personally, I think the navy looks as good as the pink! In a different way. BOTH hit my happy spot! Leaning towards keeping both! 

Yes to keeping both. I love the navy with the pearls and shoes. Gorgeous as always!

Yes to pink, but really both. That pink is way more stunning than the stock photo.

Thanks so much for indulging me and posting that photo, Angie! Love it with this strand of pearls:-) After looking at it some more, I agree: they DO both look fabulous, in their own special way. And they are going to be very versatile for you, I hope you keep both!!-)

Yes to keeping both

Sounds like you are leaning towards both, which seems like a wise choice :). I love both: The pink seems to photograph better (and is a ton of fun and looks gorgeous), but the navy looks equally fab in-person, I'm guessing.

Pink!

Please, Please tell me you are going with PINK!!!

The shape is flattering, comfortable, elegant and the style is flexible to be styled in different ways... and for that price, I would get both! they are different enough

Clearly you must keep them both. They really seem like different dresses with the color being the most outstanding feature in one and the silhouette in the other.

Pink! Hands down, the pink is my favorite.

Oh the pink one for sure. But, if you can keep both, that would be perfect.

BOTH for sure !

Love it when the answer is BOTH! FAB new dress and when it makes you happy - why not keep both!! The sleeve length, neckline, ruching - all perfect for you!

Yay - as both suit you so well!

Yay!! But I must know - which was Greg's fave?

Life is short. Keep both!

Yay!! That’s the way to go,enjoy both of them,they will probably fill slightly different niches in your wardrobe.

Yay! That's the way to do it!

Doing a happy dance for you, Angie! You will love both!!!