Shannon can I say that I am not sure of either of these? Both are nice but they just don't grab me and say "Shannon". I think I might just keep looking to be sure.

Another vote for #1

Sorry I'm so late popping back in. Just not enough hours in the day lately you know!

Thanks so much for your insights and wisdom ladies but guess what? I've decided not to get another watch at all but instead tuck a few more dollars away and get new glasses next month after my eye exam. I'm struggling with my vision these days so know that my prescription is changing again which means new specs are on the horizon.

That's a good plan! Up to date specs are important. I'm getting new lenses tomorrow, but I'm keeping my frames (didn't find ones that were as nice).

Looking forward to the spec hunt!