I love the 3rd picture color green then stripes perfect.

What a great skirt for you, Peri! You look terrific in all of these. The black is lovely as well -- only you know how often it would be worn.

Success!

Hi Peri--I just logged on to look to see if you had posted pictures, because mine arrived at my house this afternoon! Will post pictures soon. I got the striped one also in petite, and a black lace one in regular. Glad you got the ball rolling!
These look great on you! My favorites here are 2,3,5 & 6. Very flattering fit.

Yay Peri! Aren't the tube skirts fab? Are you really only keeping one? They both look fab and I love the tops you styled them with!

If you have to keep one, I think you'll get a lot more mileage with the striped skirt. They look fabulous with black, white and bold colours!!!!

1 has launched me into an orbit! Wow. And you thought these skirts won't flatter you! The striped skirt is a definite keep like everyone else has observed! You are right in that it's different than a black skirt and adds visual interest to a plain outfit. I think all the tops you have shown work well.

Wow, they are all a hit! Love esp nr 1 and 5!

Keep both! For sure the striped one, as everyone else has mentioned too. It will be interesting to compare the ruched one as well, but a black version would be nice as well, no? Haha just enabling.

I absolutely ADORE that EF top in #1. I have my eye out for that - it looks fantastic on you.

I vote for the stripe too!
I recently tried on a longer asymmetrical hem top with a tube skirt, and the salesperson told me to make the skirt a bit shorter than the length I had. I gave it a try, and what a difference it made. You've got great legs, so maybe play around with the length of the skirt depending on what top you have on.

All the outfits look great. I think I mentioned in another thread that I reach for my striped skirt more than my black one! However I'm glad I have the black one because I wear it when I have to wear black and white or black and red for choir! So my recommendation is either keep the striped, or keep the striped and the black, but don't keep just the black. As others have said, there are many black skirt options out there.

Chiming in late but definitely keep the striped one. I'm a little prejudiced toward the stripe since I just ordered it myself. I hope it looks half as good on me as it does on you. Great job with the outfits and I agree that the blue print top might really look great with the striped skirt. I love to mix patterns!

I am very partial to the 'striped tube skirt+coloured top' formula! I vote for the striped one!

This really makes me wish I had an asymmetrical hem top to wear with my own VC skirts. Amazing styling! I'm bookmarking this post for my own inspiration.