I completely missed this thread!
First, Tanya - did you find your top yet?
Also, having met Tanya in real life, I can say that she looks gorgeous in long hair. Long hair is perfect for her. She has the height to pull it off, for one thing, and her hair is very beautiful (as is the rest of her!). It's glossy and soft and healthy looking - no split ends or frizzes or anything like that (which can happen with long hair).
I have never been able to grow my hair longer than a few inches past my shoulders without it getting limp lifeless and split-endy, so I noticed this and admired this about Tanya's hair immediately when we met.
And Tanya, it's no "security blanket" that you are hiding behind!! It frames your face and falls gracefully down your back. It's, as my mother likes to say "your crowning glory." You look quite chic with long hair.
Okay enough making Tanya blush.
Ana - I'm so excited about you going short!!! Like you, I went through a very long phase where I had shoulder-length hair but nearly always pulled it back in a ponytail. Like you, my DH didn't want me to cut it short. Except he REALLY didn't want me to go short - he prefers long hair on women.
As a quickish aside - this is something I've never understood. Between my two marriages I briefly dated a man who had long Fabio-length hair. I have to say that, um, when we were kissing and such, his hair kept getting in my mouth and I just couldn't figure out how guys can put up with that. LOL.
Anywayyyyyyy.... now that I've said way too much....
I'd had super-pixie cuts in the past (when my kids were babies) and enjoyed the wash-and-go nature of such a cut. But, as Angie rightly points out, super pixies definetly require some sort of color or highlighting to add depth. Otherwise, you end up with what I call the "dreaded mom helmet" look. I have pics and when I get around to scanning them, you can see me sporting the mom helmet. Looking at the pics, I now realize it wasn't the cut per se, it was the lack of coloring to add interest.
I finally went short with this graduated bob - despite DH's reservations - because it's my hair and my decision. And it helped that, having worn ponytails for so long, my hair started breaking off right were the elastic would always go. IT also helped I had a really bad dye job that fried off all the ends and left them all crispy, so I had to cut them off.
When I came home with the short cut, I was worried about DH's reaction - but it turns out he LOVED it. And now he can't imagine me going longer again. And yes, he likes to kiss the back of my neck a lot lately.
Finally - when I turn 50 or 60ish, I'm planning on going back to the super-short pixie and putting my blow-dryer away forever. DH has been warned. He's seen the "mom helmet" photos and I've explained that I would add color or at that point my hair would be naturally white/silver anyway. He's got his fair warning and he thinks it will actually be cute, now that he's gotten used to me at this current length!