Agree the Frye were too normal and the Zara a no go because of comfort... but the Zara styling was really good.

Janet - yes, exactly right. I don't want 'real' cowboy boots because they're too tall for my short calves and they don't fit well under the jeans I currently wear. So, I want something ankle-height, mostly worn under full length jeans or with cropped jeans. They don't have to be super authentic, but my favorite pairs do have the authentic heavy duty sole.

Hadilly - funny that you say that. I'd wanted Acne Pistol boots for years. And then, just as the cowboy boot idea stuck in my head, I found a pair of Pistols at a consignment store! So now I do own them, and they're wonderful, although not quite the cowboy look I want. So the search continues.

(The even funnier part is that I found two pairs at the consignment store in one week, a size apart. I bought both, kept the one that fit better after wearing each of them to test them, and sold the other pair online for enough to cover the cost of both. Only time I've managed to do that, but the end result is they were free!)

Update: the Zara boots went on sale ($99) and I bought them (one size bigger - the ones shown here were too small). I fell in love with the really dramatic shape. Even if I don't wear them much, I'm so happy to own them.

The heel is higher than I'd usually wear but the arch position and weight balance are perfect, so they're very wearable. Plus my feet are strong and used to that position from Irish dance.

I'm still open to something more like the perfect R13 boots, but in the meantime, these are an exciting addition to my shoe collection.

I love those Zara boots and I think they look great with your style. enjoy wearing them! Even if you don’t wear them for long days on your feet they will be great for lighter walking days. The heel is what makes them so special imho.

Oooh! I love the Zara boots. When Zara footwear works, it works brilliantly. Angie and I and Shevia all had a pair of navy sock booties with pointed toes that lasted us YEARS. Mine were in extremely heavy rotation and I still miss them. I had them re-heeled several times but finally they were just getting too scuffed up to wear. The oxfords in my skirt and flats post are also Zara and they are amazingly comfortable!

That's great you got them for $99 rather than $170! Love it when that happens!
To me that means that if you don't wear them quite as much due to heel height, that since you love them it won't feel like such a waste if you only wear them infrequently, for love. Cheers to that!
PS I'm still curious about the final jeans choice even though I feel bad about not seeing much difference?!
ETA is it the jeans from the thrift store in your denim skirt post? They look great!