Thanks, Zap :).
Nancy, your new Docs only just squeak by my "height fit filter" - and I mentioned that. They are much more casual than Kim's boots, and the lacing detail allows for a little "ill-fit" at the top. Rest assured I do say it how I see it.
Kim is after dressy boots and my fit criteria is stricter in that regard. The boots are about an 8. I know Kim wants a 10. Thanks for being a sport, Kim.
Laura, I hope you find those Aquatalias. They are try beauties.
Zap, to answer your question - it really depends on who you ask! I hold very strong opinions about pant lengths and boot fits - other style professionals may not have the same opinion. But then, I am more lenient on jacket fits - whereas another style professionals strongly believe that a blazer should close down the front - I don't think that's a must. I really think that dressy boots should have a CLEAN fit. '70s style dressy boots can sag at the ankles because that's part of the look - but they *do* fit around the calf and aren't too tall in the shaft.
FWIW, that's my opinion. As always, it is up to you whether it means something to you.